March 17, 2012

Artifact #46: Jefferson R. Smith III




Artifact #46 from my private collection. Ok, not the most exciting item, but it does come from Soapy's son's belongings. The following comes from the website on Grant Wood's (the artist) Stone City Art Colony.

Jefferson Randolph Smith III
Jefferson R. Smith III (1887-1952) - second colony business manager

Son of the famed "Soapy Smith," a notorious con man who swindled communities in Alaska and Colorado, Jefferson Smith was born in St. Louis and would maintain lifelong ties to the state and its political scene through journalism and public relations.

His introduction to the newspaper industry came as a cub reporter for several St. Louis-area newspapers, including the St. Louis Globe-Democrat and the St. Louis Star-Times. Smith eventually became city and managing editor at The Times and entered local politics by serving as secretary of the Saint Louis County Chamber of Commerce (1926-1931). By the late 1920s, Smith had also logged tenures with newspapers in New York City, Denver (CO), and Miami (FL). Smith was appointed publicity secretary to Mayor Bernard F. Dickmann, organizer of the future Jefferson National Expansion Monument -- Eero Saarinen's arch and riverfront park. Political aspirations later led Smith to enter the 1933 Ferguson, Missouri race for mayor, despite his eventual loss.

Valued for his keen business sense, Smith was recruited by Adrian Dornbush, the Stone City art colony organizer, to serve as the second business manager. Despite the colony's popularity and increased enrollment for 1933, financial records showed heavy debt and the immediate need for clear accounting and sound promotional ideas. Smith accepted the position, assuming his duties in June, choosing to live at the colony and to join its art community. With his office found at the Green Mansion entrance, Smith was accessible to journalists, staff, and students, lending a professional air to the free-spirited enclave. While at Stone City, Smith met Florence Sprague, a Drake University art professor and the colony's sole female faculty member. The two married June 9, 1934 and returned to St. Louis, with Sprague resigning her academic career.

During the World War II-era, Jefferson Smith served as public relations director for various New York City firms, including Ward, Wells, and Dreschman, a nonprofit development organization. By 1947, Smith had relocated to Los Angeles, where he opened a photo studio and hobby shop; co-owner of the venture was his son, Randolph J. Smith. Florence continued painting, choosing to exhibit and sell sculptures and paintings through the family's storefront. Jefferson Smith died in Los Angeles in 1952.

Sad note: Jefferson Randolph Smith III was never given a grave marker. My son and I visited his grave last year and found that one had never been placed on his grave. The family needs to rectify this. If anyone has any ideas please contact me. In the mean time I will look into the cost of a simple, nice marker.











Jeff R. Smith III: 
February 5, 2011
February 1, 2011
November, 28, 2010
September 26, 2010
September 26, 2010
June 27, 2010
May 29, 2010
May 10, 2010
November 22, 2008










Jefferson Randolph Smith III:  pages 7, 107-08, 167, 417-18, 546, 584, 587-89.




MARCH 17
1894: Soap Gang member Billy Larimer dies. In honor of his death Soapy writes a poem and it is published in the Denver Mercury.









.

March 16, 2012

What sort of photograph inspires a film?

A street scene from The Shootist



I "finished" my Soapy Smith film inspiration page. I put finished in quote marks because I do not believe any of my pages are really ever completely finished. Periodically I may find something unique, that reminds me of something that I'd like to see in a movie on Soapy, to add to it. This is a page for artists, writers, and film makers to see pics that bring to life an instance or feeling of Soapy's life and adventures. At least the pics do something for me... I would love for people to take a look and give their opinion of the page and what it inspires, if anything.

For future reference the link to the page is on the right, under Other Important Pages and Sites.

 









.

March 15, 2012

Happy Birthday Sam Blonger














.

Ted Sweeney: unlucky Denver criminal, 1894.




In April of 1889 Soapy Smith had an auction house on Fifteenth Street that was burglarized. Here's a little story about the man, Ted Sweeney, who chose to buck Soapy's empire.

Ted Sweeney
Ted Sweeney, alias Harry Nixon alias Frank Newell, was first arrested by Denver police April 12, 1889, for burglarizing Soapy Smith's jewelry store on Fifteenth street. He was sentenced to one year in the pen. ...

The "jewelry store" is no doubt one of Soapy's auction houses where pocket watches and cheap merchandise were auctioned off to unsuspecting victims who thought they were buying gold time pieces, only to later learn that they had paid a small fortune for a cheap shiny brass watch. Mr. Sweeney made the mistake of trying to rob Soapy Smith, a man with great and powerful ties in the city. This bumbling burglar should have learned his lesson and quit his career in crime, but for reasons known only to him, he thought his luck might change after trying to rob the king of Denver's underworld; It didn't.

... On November 18, 1891, he was again arrested for burglary. He broke into a jewelry store at Alamosa. On December 15, 1891, he was sentenced to serve two years and was released September 15, 1893. He was immediately rearrested by Sheriff Lees of Douglas county and taken to the Arapahoe county jail. He was wanted on several indictments for highway robbery in Douglas county and his trial is set for next month. He was a hack driver in Denver some years ago and is well known about the city. He has a very pleasant face and a quiet disposition. He is commonly known in Denver as Ted Newell. ...

Ted Sweeney is wanted in Castle Rock for holding up John Swelgert. Sweeney fired a shot at Swelgert, who objected to losing his money. This occurred January 21, 1893.
Rocky Mountain News, 10/12/1894


While in prison Sweeney plotted a prison break with two other prisoners, Frank Murray and Jim Barlett. On the evening of October 10, 1894 the three men sawed through the window bars and made their escape into the night. In an apparent attempt to rob a train the three men began wrecking train tracks at a location about "a mile south of the Overland park crossing." A farmer happen to witness their work and informed train officials who did not take the warning serious enough but had the engineer on that particular line keep a watch. The engineer traveled slower than normal but not slow enough to stop in time. The engine and its passenger cars went off the tracks but stayed upright, thus saving lives.

The three escapees decided not to rob the train and in the early morning made their way into the town of Littleton where they robbed and tied up a store clerk. They then broke into a saloon, drinking their fill before breaking into the post office and attempted to open the safe. Someone was alarmed by the noise and the escapees fled. Behind them followed a posse of private citizens and behind that posse came various city and county lawmen from Denver. The citizens posse quickly gave up but the lawmen pursued the escapees through the following day. A fresh posse was formed and went after the 3 escapees the next day.

Unfortunately, I did not realize at the time that Ted Sweeney was one of the escapees so I did not continue searching for the rest of the story in later dated issues of the newspapers I was researching. However, I was really only interested in Sweeney's robbery of Soapy's store. I think the point is made well enough; DON'T MESS WITH SOAPY SMITH.       




COMING UP!
  • Another saloon possibly owned by Soapy in Skagway, Alaska.
  • An eyewitness description of Clancy's saloon and Soapy's operations within. This may lead to a possible shooting that was never reported.






MARCH 15
1839: Samuel H. Blonger, Soapy’s successor in Denver, is born.
1894: Colorado Governor Waite sends Special Order No. 242 ordering the Colorado National Guard to assemble at the armory and prepare to invade city hall to force the old commissioners out.
1898: Alexander McLain, a businessman, is sandbagged and robbed in front of his home in Skagway.









.

March 12, 2012

Two Bunco victims in Colfax, Colorado 1894

"TIPPING THE HAND"
Bunco steerer #2 signals the victims poker hand player #1 to bunco steerer #3



In 1894 Denver, Colorado was witnessing one of it's toughest anti-gambling reform periods. The Populist Governor Davis Waite had succeeded in banning gambling from the capitol city.
Rules under the old board required saloons and gaming halls to close at midnight and on Sundays. The week the new board took office, it told proprietors to prepare within a few days to close their doors. The following Monday gambling establishments were ordered permanently closed by noon the next day, Tuesday, April 24, 1894. ―Alias Soapy Smith, p. 323

During past attempts of gambling reform the gaming house operators merely opened behind closed doors or opened smaller secreted rooms to continue their trade, but the new city powers were forced to crack down heavy and hard on those who disobeyed the ordinance. Many proprietors simply closed their doors while some of the larger operators made deals with the town of Colfax to open their businesses there. The corrupt politicians, mainly in the Republican party, needed their money and voting influence so within days of the "permanent" end of gambling within Denver city limits, the word was given that judges would be lenient with those who broke the ordinance and Denver became flooded with underground gambling houses. Soapy Smith, Ed Chase, and the larger firms who had opened in Colfax split their business between the neighboring communities. Denver police concentrated on the bunco men to appease the governor which forced the criminals to Colfax. Gambling in much more condensed Colfax was localized to one general area. This was good in one respect as the victims of Soapy's bunco men were funneled into their set traps. The Soap Gang was literally overrun with prey for a time. Oh happy day for the steerers. Below is a newspaper story of two victims of the bunco men in Colfax that did not make it into my book. Although Soapy or the real names of any of the Soap Gang are mentioned, in all likelihood they were Soapy's men.

~~~~~~~~~~      
BUNCO MEN IN CLOVER.
B. R. Reeves, a Young Man Here from Iowa with His Wife, Falls Into the Colfax Net and is Robbed of $1,000―D. Saunders Fleeced.

Sixteen hundred dollars in cold cash passed from the hands of B. R. Reeves into the pockets of the bunco men yesterday morning. In fact, the bunco men are finding it difficult to handle the “suckers” who fall into their hands on account of their increasing numbers. Reeves, who, at the station, gave the name of James Cherry, arrived in Denver a few days ago from his home in central Iowa. He is a young man and has the appearance of one who knows the ways of the world to a certain extent. The loss of his money has, perhaps, ruined his prospects, for the $1,600 he carried in his pockets was about all he had in the world. He is about 28 years old, of medium height, and wears a light hat and a light suit of clothes.

Reeves came here a few days ago with his young and pretty wife. They engaged rooms in a down-town hotel and Reeves ventured forth to find an investment for his money which, he unfortunately carried about him in the shape of large bills. He had heard that the mines in the Cripple Creek district were producing famously, and so visited several brokers with a view to buying a claim and settling down to hard and earnest work. Yesterday morning he took a walk on Larimer street, the bunco steerer’s rialto. A bunco man suddenly emerged from a saloon, walked up to Reeves, introduced himself as an old friend, and in a few minutes an active conversation was on between the two. Reeves, who had few friends in the city, was glad to talk to someone, and the sharper proved an agreeable talker. Reeves casually mentioned his business in Denver, and this gave the steerer a clew [sic] of which he at once took advantage. The steerer said he was a mine owner and offered to show the stranger specimens, etc., and to direct his dealings. Reeves was overjoyed, and agreed to accompany his benefactor to his home to see the specimens and talk over the mining industry, and the chances that were to be taken advantage of. In the course of half an hour Reeves was seated at a poker table in a Colfax club piling up his chips like an old hand at the game. At first he won, then he lost about $100. In trying to win back the $100 he lost the $1,500 and the game was over. He objected to this state of affairs and was given $75 to leave the town. He foolishly accepted the money, but later complained to Chief Behymer. The chief detective was engaged in discussing the political situation when Reeves called, and paid little attention to his tale. Reeves left the office, promising to return at 2 o’clock. He failed to appear at this hour and in the sleuthing department of the city hall, there is very little known of the case. Reeves was advised by the detectives to tell his story to Marshal France of Colfax. Last evening at 6:30 o’clock Reeves swore out four John Doe warrants in Woodson’s court for the arrest of the steerers. Late last night no arrests had been made.

D. Saunders, a ranchman was the second victim of the day, and his contribution to the support of the sharpers was $130. Saunders appearance marked him as a fish easily caught. He is short and stout, gray haired and has a back-woods gait which in connection with a homespun suit made him a marked man. He stopped at the Revere house at 1441 Blake street. He met “W. H. Allison” and “T. F. Fairlee,” who induced him to go into their rooms in a Sixteenth street block, for the purpose of making a deal for some cows. To while away the time a deck of cards played a prominent part, and Saunders little pile soon disappeared. City detectives were detailed on the case.

Rocky Mountain News, Sept. 1, 1894
 
~~~~~~~~~~









January 2, 2009










Denver Reform: page 323.
Behymer, Henry M.: pages 317-19, 341, 350-51.
France, Marshal of Colfax: page 342.



MARCH 12
1898: Soapy posts his infamous law and order committee of 317, “answer to warning” handbills in Skagway in response to those posted by the Committee of 101. 










.

March 10, 2012

Artist: Jefferson R. Smith




My son the artist, markered (Magic Marker) this masterpiece when he was about 5-years-old. He is a great grandson of Soapy Smith. I am the proud father.







MARCH 10
1894: Aquilla “Dick” Hawkins is shot and killed.










.

March 8, 2012

Early Skagway cabinet photograph card.

(Click image to enlarge)


The above cabinet photograph entitled Views in Vicinity of Skagway, Alaska sold on eBay recently for $68.89 a low price in my opinion. This is one of the souvenir photographs sold in Skagway in the early 1900s that I have never seen before. It measures "just under" 7" x 4-3/4," and includes 6 separate views

  • "Looking up Skagua River"
  • "View on Brackett Wagon Road"
  • "Last Resting Place of Soapy Smith"
  • "The 'Loop' White Pass and Yukon RY"
  • "Grave of Soapy Smith's Slayer"
  • "Trestle on White Pass and Yukon RY"

Very interesting is the fact that the photo of Soapy's grave marker is of the very first one which should date this cabinet card pretty early, most likely no later than 1919.





MARCH 8
1894: Colorado Governor Waite replaces fired commissioners Orr and Martin with Populist Party members, Dennis Mullins as fire commissioner and Samuel D. Barnes as police commissioner, a starting shot in the Denver City Hall War.
1898: Skagway vigilante Committee of 101 posts warning handbills for Soapy and his bunco gang to leave the area.

Jeff Smith









.

March 7, 2012

Skagway Fire: March 6, 2012

Skagway fire



Perhaps the worst fear for any historic town where the majority of the structures are made of wood is fire. Skagway, Alaska tasted that fear yesterday, March 6, 2012. I saw hints on Facebook but received the most reliable report from Jeff Brady of the Skagway, News. Here's what Jeff had to say.

"I put this up on our site last night but then they cut power to our building and still out: March 6-7 - Firefighters battling fire downtown - The 600 wing of the Skagway Westmark at Second and Spring was ablaze this evening. Firefighters were called to the scene about 11 p.m. Tuesday night and found the west side in flames, and quickly spreading due to a strong southerly wind. Firefighters are working to protect another wing of the hotel across the alley as well as other nearby businesses. The hotel is currently closed for the season, and the small 600 wing was mainly used for employee housing. It also houses the Avis rental car office, a tour counter for M and M, and Skagway Jewelry that face busy Second Ave. in the summertime. The fire was contained this morning [March 7] but it had spread to the east wall of Diamonds International, which also sustained heavy water damage. More details as they become available."
The buildings in historic district are protected with water sprinklers inside and out. Jeff Smith's Parlor is not so protected at this early stage in it's restoration.







MARCH 7
1894: Colorado Governor Waite fires commissioners Jackson Orr and D. J. Martin, but they refuse to vacate their positions, starting the Denver City Hall War.
1898: Peter Clancy Bean, a miner, is murdered along the trail. Powder burns cover his face and a .38 caliber slug is lodged in his left breast. Near his body lays his empty pocketbook.

Jeff Smith









.

March 6, 2012

Soapy Smith history scrimshawed onto ivory

Soapy Smith on ivory
(Click image to enlarge)


Soapy on ivory. I came close to naming this post that because it reminded me of Soapy on ice, the future family show that will play in larger cities one day, if we could be so unlucky.


The Soapy Smith tusk
circa 1995


My friend, Dennis Corrington, Skagway businessman extraordinaire, is the proud proprietor of  the Corrington Museum of Alaskan History which highlights the history of Alaska through 40-plus exquisitely scrimshawed walrus tusks of ivory and other incredible artifacts Dennis has acquired over the decades. The museum is also home to the world's largest baleen basket. If this is not impressive enough, access to the museum is free. This is a first class exhibit and should not be missed. It is located in Skagway near the corner of 5th and Broadway.


Dennis Corrington
The Corrington Museum of Alaskan History


  









June 12, 2011 




MARCH 6
1895: Bascomb Smith’s (Soapy's younger brother) lover of six years, Jessie Wise (known as "Jessie Smith") commits suicide in Denver, Colorado while Bascomb is doing time in prison.

Jeff Smith









.

March 4, 2012

Soapy Smith and the Web of Arachne

The Web of Arachne
by P. Le Quesne
Click image to enlarge




Back on February 1, 2012 I posted the story of discovering and defining one of the the framed print in Jeff Smith's Parlor, Soapy's saloon in Skagway, Alaska. With the aid of Steve Stapp, a fellow historian, I was not only able to gather more information about the mysterious painting, but perhaps found where Soapy came upon and purchased the print.

Why did Soapy name his saloon Jeff Smith's Parlor? To date I have yet to run into another saloon that included the term Parlor in its name. What was his influence for the name? Knowing that Soapy had a good sense of humor and consistently utilized hidden, or some might even say, subliminal, messages in his writings, such as using the address of his saloon (317 Holly) as the membership count of his law and order society when countering the vigilante committee of 101. The there was the Seal named Jeff story published in a Spokane, Washington newspaper about a seal who found it's way back "home," a brilliant ruse published by Soapy to secretly let his friends in Spokane know that he was in town. It is my belief that Soapy and his Soap Gang referred to catching victims much as a spider catches bugs in a web. Jeff Smith's Parlor was one of Soapy's "webs." I believe that his influence to use the term Parlor might have come from the poem, The Spider and the Fly published in 1829 by Mary Howitt.   


The Web of Arachne
hangs on the wall behind Soapy


The Spider and the Fly is a cautionary tale of a cunning Spider who ensnares a naive Fly through the use of seduction and flattery, much like the Soap Gang ensnares their prey. The tale is a warning against those who use flattery and charm as a front for potential evil. The opening line "Will you walk into my parlour?", often quoted as "Step into my parlour" or "Come into my parlour", has become an aphorism, often used to indicate a false offer of help or friendship that is in fact a trap. The line has been used and parodied numerous times in various works of fiction. Following is the 1829 version of the poem in its entirety.


The Spider and the Fly
by Mary Howitt

"Will you walk into my parlor?" said the Spider to the Fly,
"'Tis the prettiest little parlor that ever you did spy;
The way into my parlor is up a winding stair,
And I have many curious things to show you when you are there."
"Oh no, no," said the Fly, "to ask me is in vain;
For who goes up your winding stair can ne'er come down again."

"I'm sure you must be weary, dear, with soaring up so high;
Will you rest upon my little bed?" said the Spider to the Fly.
"There are pretty curtains drawn around, the sheets are fine and thin;
And if you like to rest awhile, I'll snugly tuck you in!"
"Oh no, no," said the little Fly, "for I've often heard it said
They never, never wake again, who sleep upon your bed!"

Said the cunning Spider to the Fly, "Dear friend, what can I do
To prove that warm affection I've always felt for you?
I have within my pantry, good store of all that's nice;
I'm sure you're very welcome - will you please take a slice?"
"Oh no, no," said the little Fly, "kind sir, that cannot be,
I've heard what's in your pantry, and I do not wish to see!"

"Sweet creature," said the Spider, "you're witty and you're wise;
How handsome are your gauzy wings, how brilliant are your eyes!
I have a little looking-glass upon my parlor shelf;
If you step in one moment, dear, you shall behold yourself."
"I thank you, gentle sir," she said, "for what you're pleased to say;
And bidding good morning now, I'll call another day."

The Spider turned him round about, and went into his den,
For well he knew the silly Fly would soon come back again;
So he wove a subtle web in a little corner sly,
And set his table ready to dine upon the Fly.
then he came out to his door again, and merrily did sing,
"Come hither, hither, pretty Fly, with the pearl and silver wing;
Your robes are green and purple, there's a crest upon your head;
Your eyes are like the diamond bright, but mine are as dull as lead."

Alas, alas! how very soon this silly little Fly,
Hearing his wily, flattering words, came slowly flitting by;
With buzzing wings she hung aloft, then near and nearer drew, -
Thinking only of her brilliant eyes, and green and purple hue;
Thinking only of her crested head - poor foolish thing! At last,
Up jumped the cunning Spider, and fiercely held her fast.
He dragged her up his winding stair, into his dismal den
Within his little parlor - but she ne'er came out again!

And now, dear little children, who may this story read,
To idle, silly, flattering words, I pray you ne'er heed;
Unto an evil counselor close heart, and ear, and eye,
And take a lesson from this tale of the Spider and the Fly.

With the poem in mind I believe Soapy came across a print of the painting The Web of Arachne and decided that it belonged on the wall of his saloon.

In Greco-Roman mythology, Arachne was a great mortal weaver who boasted that her skill was greater than that of Minerva, the Latin parallel of Pallas Athena, goddess of wisdom and crafts. Arachne refused to acknowledge that her knowledge came, in part at least, from the goddess. The offended goddess set a contest between the two weavers. According to Ovid, the goddess was so envious of the magnificent tapestry and the mortal weaver's success, and perhaps offended by the girl's choice of subjects (the loves and transgressions of the gods), that she destroyed the tapestry and loom and slashed the girl's face. “Not even Pallas nor blue-fevered Envy \ Could damn Arachne's work. \ The brown haired goddess Raged at the girl's success, struck through her loom, Tore down the scenes of wayward joys in heaven.″ Ultimately, the goddess turned Arachne into a spider. Arachne simply means "spider" in Greek (source: Wikipedia).

Where did Soapy possibly see and purchase a print of The Web of Arachne? There is a good possibility he either found a copy at the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition or in Denver.

The White City Art Company, 611 Manhattan Building, Chicago, Illinois was founded in 1893 to supply souvenirs to the 1893 Chicago Columbian Exposition, they continued to publish prints, illustrated souvenir books, and postcards in the years that followed, until they closed their doors in 1909 (source: Metropolitan Postcard Club of New York City).

According to the William J. Jenack Auction house The White City Art Company also had a location in Denver but at this time the years of operation are not known (source: William J. Jenack)

Collection of prints sold in Denver by
The White City Art Company
(circa 1893)

In 1897 The White City Art Company published Out West, the photographic story of four women who traveled across the country. On the very last page of the book is an art ad by the art company (see below). The book can be viewed and read for those who wish to (source: Google).


White City Art Company
ad for The Spider's Web
(Click image to enlarge)



 The above ad offers an 11" by 14" print of The Spider's Web, which is without a doubt, The Web of Arachne, for $1.00 from the Chicago store. The Denver location is not mentioned. The framed print shown hanging on the wall of Jeff Smith's Parlor appears to be 11" by 14."

In 1902 The White City Art Company published the book, Master Paintings of the World, Edited by Dupont Vicars. On page 184 is a print of The Web of Arachne. The photograph at the top of the page was taken from this book.

It should be noted that if Soapy purchased this print previous to 1895 then it likely hung on the walls of the Tivoli Club as well as others he operated before the opening of Jeff Smith's Parlor. 





~My sincere thanks to Steve Stapp for his help~












February 1, 2011,


Jeff Smith









.

March 2, 2012

Did Soapy Smith work as a cowboy in Canada?

IGNORANT QUESTION
Who in hell do you think wins?



Jim Lynch left the following message on the Soapy Smith Discussion Forum.
"Jeff, I ran across this in a Canadian local history book called The Leaves from the Medicine Tree, it's online.In it it says that Soapy lived and worked in Canada as a man named Jim Johnson, a refined man from a southern state. He is listed in the section called desperadoes along with Sundance."
I responded back to Jim telling him I would check it out and here is what I found. The book is entitled, Leaves from the Medicine Tree, published in 1960 by the High River Pioneers' and Old Timers Association in Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada. The book is advertised as "a history of the area influenced by the tree, and biographies of pioneers and oldtimers who came under its spell prior to 1900," and can be found at the Our Roots - Nos Racines (Canada's Local Histories Online) website.

Part four, The Cattle and the Cowmen, was "researched" and written by Bert Sheppard. Unfortunately Mr. Sheppard did not include footnotes or provenance. The part that is of interest to this blog is on pages 257-58, posted here for your enjoyment.
The next outfit to start up was the HL (monogram). They located south of the Bar U. Lord Castleton was one of the shareholders, as well as being a shareholder in the Northwest Cattle Company. These men were Irishmen. Godfrey Levinge ran the place. They bought their first cattle from Emerson and Lynch, who sold them their entire herd. In 1885 they bought a bunch from Sewell and McGinnis, that came in on the railroad from British Columbia. It was on the HL ranch during the hard winter of 1886 and ’87 that a spirit thermometer froze up at seventy-two below zero.

The Desperadoes

While most of the people that came into the country were good, solid citizens, it was only natural that there were some that were not. If things got a little hot for anyone south of the Border, it was sometimes convenient to hire with a trail herd that was going across the Medicine Line. The authorities on the American side were usually quite content to let sleeping dogs lie, as long as they did not return, and no questions were asked in the Territories as long as they behaved.

In 1884 Emmerson and Lynch brought in a trail herd of two thousand head. Some of these were sold to the Quorn and the balance to the Military Colonization Company. A very able cowman who went by the name of Joe Johnson was a trail boss.

Johnson was a very dignified Southerner, well educated, a first class roper and very handy with a six-gun. Incidently [sic] he had pretty nearly been shot to pieces in various gunfights. He wore a neatly trimmed black beard and was careful of his appearance. Although he was well liked, people took care to treat him with respect.

He got a winter job with the Bar U hauling out logs with a bull team of six bulls. The summer of 1884 he ran the Bar U wagon, left that fall and went to the Oxley as foreman. In 1885 he ran the Oxley wagon. The winter of 1885 and ’86 found him running the hotel in High River, which he rented from Buck Smith. He left the country in 1886. Herb Millar saw him in Vancouver some years later on his way to Alaska to participate in the spoils of the Yukon Gold Rush. Some people believe he was “Soapy” Smith, the notorious outlaw, who after nearly taking over Alaska, was killed in a gunfight with vigilantes on Skagway Wharf.

I do not know where Mr. Sheppard learned of the theory that Joe Johnson was Soapy but there are some holes in the story.
  • I can't really say much about the name of "Joe Johnson." We know that Soapy's birth name is Jefferson Randolph Smith II but if he had crossed the border into Canada he could have used an alias name. We know he did so when he was arrested in Juneau, Alaska in 1896 and surely that was not the first time.
  • History shows that Soapy was never a cowboy as often described in older biographies of his life. Those early biographies put the cowboy years between 1876-80, well before the 1884-86 time period described in Canada. In 1884 Soapy was traveling around cities in the United States following the fair routes working his prize package soap sell racket. The short con was very successful. Far too successful for Soapy to abandon it, cross the border and accept the low wages of a cowboy. By 1885 the con man was deeply embedded inside the criminal world of Denver and gained the alias of "Soapy" by the newspapers.
  • Mr. Sheppard states that "If things got a little hot for anyone south of the Border, it was sometimes convenient to hire with a trail herd that was going across the Medicine Line." While this may be true, there is no evidence Soapy ever crossed the border into Canada during his lifetime. As I stated earlier, in 1884 he was traveling around cities within the US working short cons. Although what he was doing was criminal in nature many of the cities did not recognize his short con sales rackets as any sort of swindle. In fact, in each city and town he applied for, and received a city business license or permit as a street vendor. In many of the locations he stayed just a few days and moved on to the next town on his list. Complaints of being swindled by his victims were most likely dropped by the victim and shunned by the local lawmen, once it was learned that Soapy was no longer within city limits. Being taken for $30 by a bunco man was hardly a reason to form an investigation, or even a posse to hunt down Soapy Smith. The point is that there is little reason Soapy would have needed to cross over the border into Canada.     
It may not be a true story but I love these folk-tales just the same!

~A big thank you to Jim Lynch for informing me of this interesting story~


Jeff Smith









.